The Brotherhood Compared to Other Dystopian Rebel Groups

 Does the Brotherhood solve all the problems associated with rebel groups in dystopias? 

When I read about Winston learning how the Brotherhood works, specifically the system of sharing information only in small pieces, and not knowing the full scale of the organization, I was confused, but also impressed. Usually part of the plot of a dystopian novel, tv show, or movie, is a rebel group that gets caught, faces setbacks, and loses people along the way while they fight for their cause. While 1984 seems to follow this pattern in that it features a rebel group where everyone is willing to sacrifice their lives for the cause, the organization solves a lot of the problems we see in other dystopias where the rebel organization itself is under attack, rather than just a few of its members. The Brotherhood is well organized by necessity, but I wonder if groups in other dystopian worlds would be able to win their respective wars much quicker if they put more effort into organizing themselves. I think it would make many stories much quicker and less interesting, so the less-organized group of rebels is necessary to the plot, but it is interesting that Orwell demonstrates how messed up the world of 1984 is by showing all the things the Brotherhood has to do to even survive. 


What are some other dystopian worlds where you think the rebel group could benefit by being organized like the Brotherhood?


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Universal Utopias

  Part of the reason the world of 1984 is so messed up, is because someone tried to create a utopia. We started the semester by defining utopia and dystopia, and discussing whether utopias are even possible. Most of the class agreed that no, a utopia in the way we normally picture it, is not possible, because everyone’s idea of a utopia is unique and involves the people around them. The world of 1984 is so messed up and different from our society because the original creators of the party wanted to create their utopia, which included total power and control, and it ruined the lives of everyone around them. I think we as a society tend to always look for ways to improve the world we live in, which is a good and necessary thing, because our world could definitely be improved upon, but I think sometimes we get caught up in that improval and don’t always think through how a decision that might make my life better, could hurt someone else. I have found that when I make an active effort to k
Read more

“All struggles are essentially power struggles”

I think I could make a case both for and against this Earthseed quote, because I can see how you could relate any struggle back to a power struggle, but I don’t think getting rid of the root of all power struggles would get rid of all struggles. I think this verse implies that because “all struggles are essentially power struggles”, by making the distribution of power perfect, you would eliminate all struggles, and that by improving the unequal distribution of power, you start to get rid of struggles. A “power struggle”, according to Merriam-Webster’s dictionary is, “a fight for control”. According to this definition, someone struggling because they don’t have enough to eat or drink is part of a power struggle because they are fighting for control over what resources they have access to and ultimately consume. If power was evenly distributed among people in our world, theoretically this person’s struggle would be solved because everyone would have enough to eat. But if the root of the
Read more

Power in 1984

Image
  What defines power?  In the last few chapters of 1984 we learn more about The Party and its motivations, the biggest being power. The Party defines power as control, the ability to do anything they want, and the respect of every single person in “the world” (Oceania). To them, power isn’t power unless it is over everything. As O’Brien puts it, this is the type of power that people like Hitler were trying to achieve, but they failed to achieve it because they retained some amount of humanness that “held them back”. I think our current world values power, but also values balance, so O’Brien would argue we don’t truly want power at all, because “power” can only be defined as total control. The reason Winston, Julia, and other thought criminals put this society at risk is because they fight for some small amount of power for themselves. Julia seeks power over her own life, the kind of power that we tend to define as “freedom”. The freedom to say what we want, believe what we want, spend
Read more